The Springboks are planning to avoid spending any more time than necessary in Hamilton by flying in from the Gold Coast just 48 hours before the game. Coach Peter de Villiers believed that his players would become apathetic if they had to spend too long in the "boring" city, saying "there is nothing in Hamilton." Nothing in Hamilton?! What about the mighty Waikato? They could visit the Hamilton Gardens, the Hamilton Zoo or one or all of the six public libraries within the city! Surely they'd be happy with a riveting read in between training sessions?
In another example of the Your Views editorial team scrounging around for potential questions to raise, they posted the question: Where is the most boring place in New Zealand?
Of course there has been a good helping of comments containing negative stereotypes of particular New Zealand towns and those speaking out in defence of these representations. However, as always there have been some responses which use the question as a vehicle to comment on seemingly unrelated political issues:
Juan O Vastaya (Browns Bay)
The most boring place in New Zealand would be Bill English's home - when the deceitful, self-serving and avaricious Finance Minister is in residence.
Why? Because it would be totally quiet as English busied himself seeing how much more he could rip-off the system for, whilst mutely composing a reminder to the rest of the country that a recession is occurring.
Which one of his two houses is the most boring?
JD (Opawa)
W[h]anganui!
All those colourful characters with gang patches gone from the streets - leaving grey conformity!
And last but not least, my favourite find of the day, commenting nicely on the possible user perceptions of the Your Views forum:
Liz (Auckland Central)
The Herald Views page is the most boring place in NZ.
Wednesday, September 9, 2009
One man's trash is another man's treasure
Auckland artist Dane Mitchell's work "Collateral" won the Trust Waikato National Contemporary Art Award 2009, an award with $15,000 in prize money. According to the Herald, the competition is known for its "challenging" and "controversial" entries. Stories with any hint of controversy are usually linked quick-smart to a Your Views question and this one was no exception. Nothing like a stimulating debate in which users get to discuss the complex nature of contemporary art. Your Views asked: Is this creation art or trash?
Dark_Nyt (Helensville)
As the saying goes "one mans trash is another mans treasure", which seems to be the case here. Although this trash is just that, trash. True artists take time and commitment to create a piece of beauty, not sucker others into tipping rubbish into a pile and calling it art.
Hold on a second there Dark_Nyt. First you say we can all have an opinion on contemporary art, or indeed anything fitting the trash/treasure turn of phrase I guess. However, then you rule that Mitchell's work is simply "trash" leaving no room for it to be considered a "treasure"!
Alisha091 (Auckland)
TRASH! Who were the judges? The locals on K road?
I love how emphatically Alisha091 jumps at the chance to respond directly to the Your Views question, using capital letters and an exclamation mark to emphasise her choice. If we excuse the "locals of K road" comment, she does point towards the inadequate coverage of the event by the Herald through asking who the judges were.
In this thread of comments, the Forum Editor gets involved in order to give Anne from Glen Eden a bit of a telling off:
Anne (Glen Eden)
DR (Ellerslie) the problem with this ?work? is that I define art as ?human creative skill?.concerned with production of imitative and imaginative designs and expression of ideas?.contrasted with scientific technique or principal?. ?Art? has, in the modern world, become synonymous with social activism, like most other things. This ?work? may be social commentary. It is not ?art?. There may be those who think that?s a valid artistic pursuit. The art world has been clearly consumed by the concept or just by anything that?s weird or eccentric but I still prefer ?art? to be beautiful, to require toil, creativity and skill. It has nothing to do with socialism. It has everything to do with finding enough ugliness in the world and looking to ?art? to lift the human spirit. All that can be derived from this ?work? is, as someone said, that we would all be enlightened by taking a picnic lunch and bottle of wine to the local landfill for a day of reflection to marvel at the apparent creativity of those who generated it and those who dumped it. Whatever someone believes, there?s nothing imaginative or creative in this or in the social facts to enjoy
FORUM EDITOR'S NOTE: Anne, this is how your emails appear to us when they arrive. If you type you message directly into the Herald's message box, rather than cutting and pasting from another program, then the '?' marks will appear as apostrophes - as they should. Also, please check how long you messages are. 90 per cent of them cut off mid-sentence.
As a none-time poster but long-time reader of Your Views, I can say this is the first time I've seen such a thing! Poor Anne is publicly shamed in front of her fellow Your Views users. Surely the forum editor could have sent her an email? The inclusion of this note on Anne's post not only undermines what she has to say, but it makes visible the role of moderation in the forum and therefore serves a reminder that the Your Views editorial team have the ultimate say in how user responses are represented.
Dark_Nyt (Helensville)
As the saying goes "one mans trash is another mans treasure", which seems to be the case here. Although this trash is just that, trash. True artists take time and commitment to create a piece of beauty, not sucker others into tipping rubbish into a pile and calling it art.
Hold on a second there Dark_Nyt. First you say we can all have an opinion on contemporary art, or indeed anything fitting the trash/treasure turn of phrase I guess. However, then you rule that Mitchell's work is simply "trash" leaving no room for it to be considered a "treasure"!
Alisha091 (Auckland)
TRASH! Who were the judges? The locals on K road?
I love how emphatically Alisha091 jumps at the chance to respond directly to the Your Views question, using capital letters and an exclamation mark to emphasise her choice. If we excuse the "locals of K road" comment, she does point towards the inadequate coverage of the event by the Herald through asking who the judges were.
In this thread of comments, the Forum Editor gets involved in order to give Anne from Glen Eden a bit of a telling off:
Anne (Glen Eden)
DR (Ellerslie) the problem with this ?work? is that I define art as ?human creative skill?.concerned with production of imitative and imaginative designs and expression of ideas?.contrasted with scientific technique or principal?. ?Art? has, in the modern world, become synonymous with social activism, like most other things. This ?work? may be social commentary. It is not ?art?. There may be those who think that?s a valid artistic pursuit. The art world has been clearly consumed by the concept or just by anything that?s weird or eccentric but I still prefer ?art? to be beautiful, to require toil, creativity and skill. It has nothing to do with socialism. It has everything to do with finding enough ugliness in the world and looking to ?art? to lift the human spirit. All that can be derived from this ?work? is, as someone said, that we would all be enlightened by taking a picnic lunch and bottle of wine to the local landfill for a day of reflection to marvel at the apparent creativity of those who generated it and those who dumped it. Whatever someone believes, there?s nothing imaginative or creative in this or in the social facts to enjoy
FORUM EDITOR'S NOTE: Anne, this is how your emails appear to us when they arrive. If you type you message directly into the Herald's message box, rather than cutting and pasting from another program, then the '?' marks will appear as apostrophes - as they should. Also, please check how long you messages are. 90 per cent of them cut off mid-sentence.
As a none-time poster but long-time reader of Your Views, I can say this is the first time I've seen such a thing! Poor Anne is publicly shamed in front of her fellow Your Views users. Surely the forum editor could have sent her an email? The inclusion of this note on Anne's post not only undermines what she has to say, but it makes visible the role of moderation in the forum and therefore serves a reminder that the Your Views editorial team have the ultimate say in how user responses are represented.
Engineered to fail
Peter Hughes, a maths lecturer from the University of Auckland, claims that only a third of New Zealand students entering secondary school are numerate. Hughes makes this claim in light of the fact that a numeracy test he has created was seen as rather difficult by an unnamed secondary school's maths department head. The story even includes the test in question, which is assumed 70% of Year 11 students would fail, for readers to have a go at and click a link for the solutions. Now that's what I call interactivity.
In true form to Your Views, the problems and pitfalls of an entire education system come under scrutiny because of one person's specific claim about a specific topic - rates of numeracy in secondary school students. Your Views asks: Does the NZ education system fail to cover the basics? not "What are your impressions of the NZ education system?" or anything of a similarly open nature. Alongside the article and standing on its own, the question is coded with meaning and works to trigger responses that argue the NZ education does "fail to cover the basics".
The question has obviously encouraged those who seek to list one by one the evil temptations and trappings of modern childhood and how children are helpless victims of "brainwashing".
Help Us ASAP! (Auckland Central)
May be or may be not but it has a lot to do with the socialisation of what they learn at school. They may learn maths and writing at school, but in reality they are brainwashed by the media in TV, Video Games, GE foods, chemical drinks, and inappropriate peer pressure
Brainwashing!
Lucy in the Sky (Auckland Central)
Our schools focus on brainwashing the kids about nukes, the environment, global warming, eating right, charity, multiculturalism and political correctness, when all of these are the domain of the parent. They should be teaching school stuff, like reading, writing, maths, history, physics, chemistry, biology & geography. Stuff that matters.
More brainwashing! I'm confused about what "matters" according to Lucy in the Sky - surely things that are in the "domain of the parent" should be the things that "matter" most?
ryan (Bahamas)
Lazyness is also to blame. Too much tv and xbox and sports. I say throw away the TV, get some strict discipline in schools and bugger this pc nonsense that's destroyed NZ. Hell when i was at school there was nothing wrong with a good spanking, and good old fashioned discipline, short hair for boys etc,we are not making good citizens here
I get the feeling Ryan thinks a short haircut and a good spank would sort out a lot of the problems in New Zealand.
After all this talk of brainwashing and spanking, let's leave today's post with a thoughful response from bob of the Bay of Plenty. Three cheers for bob for putting his thinking cap on a little before clicking "send".
bob (Bay Of Plenty)
I'm a little puzzled by this article. Peter Hughes states that just a third of students are entering secondary school numerate and backs this up by using a comment from a secondary school teacher. Where's the research that backs up this highly inflammatory comment?
Further on in the article it states that Ministry of Education figures show our students are above the OECD average. So who is right here, the lecturer whose comments are backed up by a second hand comment from someone else. Or the Government department with research from a world renowned organisation?
Before jumping on this teacher bashing bandwagon I think some more considered research into this issue would be needed.
In true form to Your Views, the problems and pitfalls of an entire education system come under scrutiny because of one person's specific claim about a specific topic - rates of numeracy in secondary school students. Your Views asks: Does the NZ education system fail to cover the basics? not "What are your impressions of the NZ education system?" or anything of a similarly open nature. Alongside the article and standing on its own, the question is coded with meaning and works to trigger responses that argue the NZ education does "fail to cover the basics".
The question has obviously encouraged those who seek to list one by one the evil temptations and trappings of modern childhood and how children are helpless victims of "brainwashing".
Help Us ASAP! (Auckland Central)
May be or may be not but it has a lot to do with the socialisation of what they learn at school. They may learn maths and writing at school, but in reality they are brainwashed by the media in TV, Video Games, GE foods, chemical drinks, and inappropriate peer pressure
Brainwashing!
Lucy in the Sky (Auckland Central)
Our schools focus on brainwashing the kids about nukes, the environment, global warming, eating right, charity, multiculturalism and political correctness, when all of these are the domain of the parent. They should be teaching school stuff, like reading, writing, maths, history, physics, chemistry, biology & geography. Stuff that matters.
More brainwashing! I'm confused about what "matters" according to Lucy in the Sky - surely things that are in the "domain of the parent" should be the things that "matter" most?
ryan (Bahamas)
Lazyness is also to blame. Too much tv and xbox and sports. I say throw away the TV, get some strict discipline in schools and bugger this pc nonsense that's destroyed NZ. Hell when i was at school there was nothing wrong with a good spanking, and good old fashioned discipline, short hair for boys etc,we are not making good citizens here
I get the feeling Ryan thinks a short haircut and a good spank would sort out a lot of the problems in New Zealand.
After all this talk of brainwashing and spanking, let's leave today's post with a thoughful response from bob of the Bay of Plenty. Three cheers for bob for putting his thinking cap on a little before clicking "send".
bob (Bay Of Plenty)
I'm a little puzzled by this article. Peter Hughes states that just a third of students are entering secondary school numerate and backs this up by using a comment from a secondary school teacher. Where's the research that backs up this highly inflammatory comment?
Further on in the article it states that Ministry of Education figures show our students are above the OECD average. So who is right here, the lecturer whose comments are backed up by a second hand comment from someone else. Or the Government department with research from a world renowned organisation?
Before jumping on this teacher bashing bandwagon I think some more considered research into this issue would be needed.
Labels:
PC gone mad,
This country's gone soft
Tuesday, September 8, 2009
The Tree Murderers
The Herald reported on the Government's desire to make it easier for landowners to cut down trees on their own property. A triumph for the libertarians! "I'm sick of being told what I can and can't do on my own property, now I can cut down all the trees I like!" Although it's not quite that simple, so don't run to the shed for your chainsaw just yet. The Government proposes that people still couldn't take an axe to any trees listed as protected trees in their specific council's district plan.
So Your Views pits the Greenies against the Freedom-loving Chainsaw-Happy Folks with the question: Is it a good move to make it easier to chop down and trim trees?
And here was I thinking the world relied on trees to keep us alive? Chainsaw at the ready, the trees are giving us asthma!
Perhaps this user was provoked by the Herald's Interesting choice of headline for the related story: 'Law changes could see open season on trees'. It does invoke shooting spree connotations, with "JK" and his big-shot mates decked out in trenchcoats ready for a tree massacre.
Tim C (North Shore)
Why is it that the 'left wing' in this discussion crudely and nievely conclude this tree debate is all about "greedy developers" (when they make up less than 1% of the population)?. You communists show your true colours. You want sameism & differing views to yours just isn't to be tolerated is it!. Big brother nanny state must intervene to control our every move, tell us what we can and can't do, that we can't cut our own tree on our own residential property or the East German neighbours (you) will dob us in!. Its called the tall poppy syndrome. You just cant stand someone being an achiever in any form of commerce ie; property, uncomfortably (for you) more of an achiever than you could ever be!. You need the state to control everyone so that it makes you feel good. You need to complain about the developers, or big business making far far too much money when most know that kind of debate is childish. Grow up! (some of you will achieve that with maturity & some of you will just never get it!).What sad creatures you are!. You would be more at home in the old Soviet Union wouldn't you, plenty of trees there!, but that was a hopelessly failed experiment wasn't it !.
I don't know where to start! What I can say is that I'm very sure Tim C isn't looking for an open and engaged discussion, with the possibility of having his own opinion challenged. The communist theme is incredibly consistent. The "you" being addressed is obviously any Your Views user of '"left-wing" political leanings but Tim C takes it as far as to call such people nanny-state lovin', East German communists who don't want to cut down trees but are the first to hack down tall poppies.
So Your Views pits the Greenies against the Freedom-loving Chainsaw-Happy Folks with the question: Is it a good move to make it easier to chop down and trim trees?
machan (Onehunga)
Most of these Greenies do not understand the health hazards of two many trees around the houses.It is one of the main cause for cold,damp houses which in turn causes asthma and other upper respiratory infections etc.More over trees around the houses prevent people from getting sun light which is very important for Vit,D metabolism which is important to prevent children from suffering with Rickets and adults from Osteoporosis.And here was I thinking the world relied on trees to keep us alive? Chainsaw at the ready, the trees are giving us asthma!
Lady Barbie Girl (Epsom)
JK's right-wing National government will be remembered, not only in New Zealand but also world-wide, as "The Tree Murderers". Simply because no other government in the Western world allows such cynical killing of trees.Perhaps this user was provoked by the Herald's Interesting choice of headline for the related story: 'Law changes could see open season on trees'. It does invoke shooting spree connotations, with "JK" and his big-shot mates decked out in trenchcoats ready for a tree massacre.
Tim C (North Shore)
Why is it that the 'left wing' in this discussion crudely and nievely conclude this tree debate is all about "greedy developers" (when they make up less than 1% of the population)?. You communists show your true colours. You want sameism & differing views to yours just isn't to be tolerated is it!. Big brother nanny state must intervene to control our every move, tell us what we can and can't do, that we can't cut our own tree on our own residential property or the East German neighbours (you) will dob us in!. Its called the tall poppy syndrome. You just cant stand someone being an achiever in any form of commerce ie; property, uncomfortably (for you) more of an achiever than you could ever be!. You need the state to control everyone so that it makes you feel good. You need to complain about the developers, or big business making far far too much money when most know that kind of debate is childish. Grow up! (some of you will achieve that with maturity & some of you will just never get it!).What sad creatures you are!. You would be more at home in the old Soviet Union wouldn't you, plenty of trees there!, but that was a hopelessly failed experiment wasn't it !.
I don't know where to start! What I can say is that I'm very sure Tim C isn't looking for an open and engaged discussion, with the possibility of having his own opinion challenged. The communist theme is incredibly consistent. The "you" being addressed is obviously any Your Views user of '"left-wing" political leanings but Tim C takes it as far as to call such people nanny-state lovin', East German communists who don't want to cut down trees but are the first to hack down tall poppies.
Monday, September 7, 2009
Some tough bikkies with that cup of tea?
It's no wonder that after losing out big time at the Qantas Film and Television Awards, TV3 don't feel like sharing. Usually TVNZ and TV3 alternate years of filming and screening of the awards ceremony and this year was TVNZ's turn, but they pulled out and TV3 took up the opportunity to cover the event. It's also no surprise that TV3 didn't screen the entire event but simply a "highlights" version, in which they conveniently edited out many of TVNZ's winners. TVNZ missed out, but they won big, and therefore want the footage so they can have a wee gloat.
TVNZ spokeswoman Andi Brotherston said that TV3 giving them access to the footage would be "a gracious thing to do." TV3 spokesman Roger Beaumont replied by saying: "They need to go sit down and have a cup of tea, to be quite frank."
How did the Your Views users feel? Should TV3 hand over Qantas Awards footage to TVNZ? Or should we all sit down with a nice cuppa and let bygones be bygones?
Karen (Sunnynook)
The media in this country are of such a pitifully low standard they should be embarrassed to have awards at all. No wonder their advertising revenue has plummeted. Their big corporate spenders are all out of here and who watches them these days anyway?
Perhaps if they didn't spend so much on obscenely inflated salaries, corporate cabs, $1k lunches, $60 bottles of wine, expensive wardrobes etc they could have covered it themselves or offered TV3 a reasonable fee for a copy. Profligate wallies.
Again, a intricately-detailed description of someone's impression of a group of people. The accumulation of these "bad" habits are no doubt employed to support the idea that commercial media are blinded by their own decadence, painted as bacchanalian figures who are so consumed by the need for self-satisfaction that they ignore reason.
Opinion8d (Te Atatu South)
Why should they? TV3 filmed the awards, they get to keep the footage. Simple. Besides, April (Auckland) is right; they all produce a load of rubbish - I stopped watching mainstream television about ten years ago, and I'm pretty certain that I'm not alone out there.
And yet you still read the Herald...
Neal (Dargaville)
Tough bikkies TVNZ
Nice one Neal, simply put! On that note, I might go put the jug on...
TVNZ spokeswoman Andi Brotherston said that TV3 giving them access to the footage would be "a gracious thing to do." TV3 spokesman Roger Beaumont replied by saying: "They need to go sit down and have a cup of tea, to be quite frank."
How did the Your Views users feel? Should TV3 hand over Qantas Awards footage to TVNZ? Or should we all sit down with a nice cuppa and let bygones be bygones?
Karen (Sunnynook)
The media in this country are of such a pitifully low standard they should be embarrassed to have awards at all. No wonder their advertising revenue has plummeted. Their big corporate spenders are all out of here and who watches them these days anyway?
Perhaps if they didn't spend so much on obscenely inflated salaries, corporate cabs, $1k lunches, $60 bottles of wine, expensive wardrobes etc they could have covered it themselves or offered TV3 a reasonable fee for a copy. Profligate wallies.
Again, a intricately-detailed description of someone's impression of a group of people. The accumulation of these "bad" habits are no doubt employed to support the idea that commercial media are blinded by their own decadence, painted as bacchanalian figures who are so consumed by the need for self-satisfaction that they ignore reason.
Opinion8d (Te Atatu South)
Why should they? TV3 filmed the awards, they get to keep the footage. Simple. Besides, April (Auckland) is right; they all produce a load of rubbish - I stopped watching mainstream television about ten years ago, and I'm pretty certain that I'm not alone out there.
And yet you still read the Herald...
Neal (Dargaville)
Tough bikkies TVNZ
Nice one Neal, simply put! On that note, I might go put the jug on...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)